| Class of 2005 | ||
| Name | High School | College |
| Jenn Flaherty | Athens Drive | North Carolina |
| Ashley Rupert | Green Hope | NC State Club |
| Chrissy Sibley | Green Hope | George Mason/NC State Club |
| Class of 2006 | ||
| Name | High School | College |
| Sarah Lefebvre | Green Hope | Pfeiffer |
| Nina Mancuso | Enloe | Salisbury |
| Molly O'Brien | Cardinal Gibbons | Connecticut |
| Class of 2007 | ||
| Name | High School | College |
| Allison Faulhaber | Apex | St. Andrews |
| Taylor Ketchum | Top Sail | Old Dominion |
| Cori Niemann | Cape Fear Academy | Sewanee: Univ of the South |
| Taylor Raczkowski | East Chapel Hill | Robert Morris |
| Nikki Ray | South Guilford | Salisbury |
| Class of 2008 | ||
| Name | High School | College |
| Sarah Bull | Western Guilford | Navy |
| Lauren Cosentino | Green Hope | North Carolina |
| Laura Escobar | Broughton | North Carolina |
| Alexis "Lexi" Slutsky | Wakefield | Slippery Rock |
| Class of 2009 | ||
| Name | High School | College |
| Sarah Fellows | Apex | Ohio State |
| Courtney McLaughlin | Apex | North Carolina |
| Pauline Weissman | Greensboro Country Day | Columbia |
| Katie Worsdale | Green Hope | St. Mary’s |
